okay, i think we can stop the competition right here. i wasn't quite sure i wanted to jump the gun so early last week, but this week confirmed it... if melinda doolittle does not win it would be a damn shame. well actually, maybe not. i mean, when the show started out it was only the winner that would be the change to make it, but now it seems like if you're on the screen for 20 seconds you'll get your record deal and the winner is handcuffed by whatever contract they've got. blah, whatever, how many cds of idol winners have i bought? ZERO. so really, they just entertain me while i watch the show and then when 8:00 comes around i'm off to listen to real music.
anyway, i think that black back up singer is so far and away the best one there, girls or guys, it's not even funny. but since i'm not gonna run out and buy her cds if she wins or not, i'm content to watch her be great on this little tv show. see, even though it was an old kinda song, she create so many little musical moments with her dynamics, phrasing, embellishments that it was neat to listen to the whole way through. very controlled and seemed like she had the whole song planned out phrasing-wise (not like those other sing 'till you're yelling girls), i think those other contestants should really take a listen and learn from her.
but then again, if they were all that good then where would the fun be? no one to critique? no one to insult? what kind of tv show would that be? i'll tell you what kind... the crappy kind. so keep it going, and i'll just be thankful that they DO have a great singer to listen to inbetween all those other wannabes (not that the wannabes aren't any fun, but it's a nice relief to know that i'm guaranteed to like at least one of the 10 performances each night).
okay, off the soapbox now... time for ratings (because i've already bought into this production so i might as well stick with it and be a mainstream american):
1. melinda doolittle - of course, too bad she has no neck though
2. stephanie edwards - see? i'm starting to learn their names! i like that she sang a beyonce song, and it wasn't that bad
3. lakisha jones - i didn't like her last week, but she sounded more free flowing this week, so i'll give her props.
who can leave?
the two beautiful girls... too bad their voices don't hold up.
ps - since i'm on the subject of tv... lost is lame. do you think they could actually make stuff happen on that show sometime? take a page from "heroes," y'know that show with an actual storyline?




#2. first white girl - i don't remember her at all. didn't quite pull off that song, i ain't mad at her, but didn't sound too good. blah, no care.
#3. creepy looking white girl - man she looks weird. shouldn't have picked that song, i think everyone remembers kelly clarkson singing that one the first time around and her voice i actually like, but that kind of big loud song doesn't match it. anyway, she can stay though (despite the unfortunate creepy looks).
#4. big nose black girl - i like her. kinda rough with the song, but that's the kind of song i like to see people singing. don't mess around with the campy crap, just go right for it, that was good. she must stay.
#5. antonella girl - well, i remember her name, but i didn't like her after she got put through instead of that other marisa girl (who i REALLY liked). but now i feel sorry for antonella. she seems like the amateur girl who went on american idol because she had a nice voice and wanted to see if should could be really good (as opposed to all those backup singers and cruise ship workers who were already kinda in the business). so that makes me want to root for her. but the song was kinda crappy, there was one little nice part at the very end, but overall very sad. however, i would actually like to see her get through one more week... also, she's very pretty :)
#6. the 17-year-old - this one i like. most definately. i like the way she tempo-ed that song (and it was good song choice too) and added her whatevers at the end. i like her style. she's my early pick for the finals.
#7. another white girl - what the crap was that? a bunch of shouting? i don't know what she was trying to do, and she didn't sound good doing it. she can go home. 

#10. another white girl i don't remember - junk... i can see where there's something in her voice that sounds kinda nice... but junk, go home.
#11. punk white girl i don't like - okay i still don't like her (annoyingly arrogant), but she sings pretty well. the thing that did it though was that music break right before the end of the song. I LOVE THAT! if i wrote songs every single one would have that music break, like that late 80's early 90's love ballad music break where everything drops and then the big note or whatever. y'know like in that (i'm sad that i'm using this song to compare it to, but it's the only one i can think of right now) nsync song, um... that's when i'll stop loving you. it had one of those breaks in it. just that little arrangement change made me like her performance, she can stay.
#12. big black girl - i didn't think it was that good. blah, she screamed the whole thing. but she can stay another week that'd be fine.













